Last updated on September 3rd, 2023
Choosing the best crossbow broadheads can be a daunting task. There are tons of options in a wide variety of shapes and sizes, and nearly as many different opinions about which ones you should shoot.
This article will help you pick the best crossbow broadhead for the upcoming deer season by narrowing down the choices to 10 of the best fixed blade, mechanical and hybrid options available and providing in-depth information on each.
In the end, which you choose will depend on your personal preferences, which perform best in your crossbow, and what you feel most confident shooting.
With that, let’s dive straight into our top 10 picks, since that’s what you’re really here for.
Best Fixed Blade Broadheads
Best Mechanical Broadheads
Best Hybrid Broadheads
Best Fixe Blade Broadheads
Editor’s Choice* QAD Exodus Broadhead
The unique design of the QAD Exodus puts most of the three 0.040-inch thick blades over the arrow shaft, giving it a super compact profile that flies like a field point, even with a larger 1 1/4 cutting diameter.
The steep cutting angle and hardened SST tip provide devastating penetration and consistent pass-throughs. And like the Excalibur and Muzzy, the blades are the QAD Exodus are replaceable so you can keep them razor sharp at all times.
You undoubtedly know the Excalibur name for their line of quality crossbows, but they also have their own broadheads as well. The Boltcutter is a beefy, fixed blade broadhead made for durability and accuracy. The head features a large stainless steel ferrule and three vented stainless steel blades packing a 1 1/16-inch cutting diameter.
The Boltcutter weighs in at 150 grains, making it the heaviest broadhead on my list, and perfect for the crossbow hunter looking for a heavy arrow setup with high FOC. The convenient Center Locking System (CLS) allows blade replacement without removing the broadhead from the crossbow bolt.
The G5 Montec M3 is a one-piece, fixed blade, cut-on-contact broadhead made of 420 stainless steel. The solid, non-vented design reduces noise in flight and increases strength and durability.
These American-made broadheads are razor sharp and 100% spin tested for accuracy. If you want a solid, fixed blade broadhead for your crossbow in 100 grain weight, then the G5 Montec M3 may be the perfect broadhead for your next deer season.
The Muzzy Trocar is a fixed blade broadhead that features a strong stainless steel ferrule and three vented, .035-inch blades proving a total cutting diameter of 1 3/16 inches. The compact design, heavy trocar tip, and right-offset blades give the broadhead field-tip accuracy and bone-breaking penetration.
Best Expandable Broadheads
Editor’s Choice* RAGE Crossbow X
Nobody sells more mechanical broadheads annually than Rage. Rage has a wide variety of broadhead options, including some specifically designed for crossbows.
The Rage Crossbow X is the most popular of those. The Crossbow X is a 2-blade broadhead with a cut-on-contact tip, available in both 100 or 125 grain weights.
The ferrule is constructed of aluminum with .035-inch stainless steel blades that are held in place by Rage’s shock collar retention system and deployed by their patented Slipcam technology.
Best of all, Rage broadheads are manufactured in the U.S.
If I was going back to mechanicals this season, I would likely go with the G5 Deadmeat. Their compact design makes them fly like field points, and their all-steel construction keeps them intact.
The Snaplock blade retention design can be a little finicky, but when used properly keeps the blades securely locked in place until impact. The G5 Deadmeat also comes with a Ballistic Match Point practice tip that flies just like the actual broadheads.
Designed for specifically for high speed crossbows, the Grim Reaper Pro Series crossbow head is tested field point accurate at speeds over 400FPS out to 100 yards.
The heads feature three blades that deploy from the front, similar to the Swhacker, with a 1 1/2 inch cutting diameter. I couldn’t find any information on what material the ferrule and blades are made from, but I have to assume the blades are stainless steel.
Unlike the other broadheads featured here, Grim Reaper Pro Series broadheads come in a pack of four rather than three.
I’ll be the first to admit that I’m not a big fan of front deploying broadheads, but there are a lot of die-hard Swhacker users out there, and they have excellent reviews on Amazon.
Swhackers feature two separate cutting edges. The wing blades take most of the punishment cutting through the hair and hide, deploying the .032-inch main blades in the body cavity to cut through internal organs.
The three pack of Swhacker broadheads comes with extra bands and a practice head.
Best Hybrid Broadheads
Get the best of both worlds – fixed blade and mechanical — with a unique hybrid broadhead design. The Muzzy Trocar HBX Crossbow broadhead features several of the same great characteristics of the Muzzy tip we discussed above, except with a unique hybrid design with both fixed and expandable blades.
The head includes two offset fixed blades with a 1-inch cutting diameter and two expandable blades with a 1 5/8-inch cutting diameter. Both are .035 inch thickness.
The Bloodsport Cut-on-Contact Grave Digger broadhead is unique in that you can lock down the mechanical arms and shoot the broadhead as a fixed blade head with a 1-inch main cutting diameter and 1/2-inch bleeder veins.
Or, if you prefer, you can loosen the set screw and shoot it as a true hybrid with the 1-inch main cutting diameter and 1 3/4-inch cutting diameter expandable blades.
A patented blade retention system keeps the blades closed until entry without the need for rubber bands or O-rings that may fail.
Broadhead Features to Consider
Fixed Blade or Mechanical
The debate over whether fixed blade or mechanical broadheads are better is as old as mechanical broadheads themselves. I’m not here to sway you one way or the other when it comes to choosing the best crossbow broadhead for your use.
I’ve used both and killed deer with both. I’m currently shooting a fixed blade broadhead that I’m very happy with, but that doesn’t mean next season won’t find my Black Eagle arrows tipped with the latest, greatest mechanical broadhead.
If you’re undecided on which you want to shoot this year, I will offer some thoughts to help you make the best decision for your needs.
Personally, I lean toward using fixed blade heads for a few reasons. First and foremost, since they lack any mechanical features, there is a much less likelihood of broadhead failure in any way.
You never have to worry about whether the blades deploy upon impact or if the blades deployed early. Secondly, I like the immediate cutting action on contact that maximizes the momentum of the arrow.
Again, since no blades are having to move during deployment, there is less energy lost by the arrow upon impact. This improves your odds of a pass-thru shot even if the shot fails to hit the intended mark.
Having said that, fixed blade broadheads face at least one issue that most mechanicals don’t: they don’t always fly true from a particular bow or crossbow, and those issues can really be compounded with today’s fast-shooting equipment.
Mechanical broadheads often feature larger cutting diameters than their fixed blade counterparts, which can create more damage and much more obvious blood trails. On the flip side, though, that larger cutting diameter requires more momentum to push all the way through the animal, reducing the chance of a pass-thru shot.
If you do choose to go with a mechanical broadhead, be aware that they come in both rear deploying and forward deploying models. Rage and G5 both produce popular rear deploying broadheads where the blades are pushed straight back and deployed upon impact.
On front deploying broadheads like the Swhacker, the blades actually pivot from the back of the broadhead and have to rotate over the pivot point as they get pushed back from the front. In my mind, this requires a lot more energy than a rear deploying configuration.
There is also concern with the broadheads deflecting on sharp quartering shots. If I’m going to use a mechanical broadhead, it’s going to be a rear deploying model for those reasons.
So as you can see, there’s no clear “best” option here. Each has its pros and cons. My advice is to shoot a cut-on-contact fixed blade broadhead if you can get them to fly true and group well from your crossbow. If not, then a good mechanical, rear deploying broadhead with a moderate (2 inch or below) cutting diameter should do the trick.
Most crossbow broadheads are going to come in either 100, 125 or 150 grains, with 100 grains being the most common. Any of these will work effectively. It’s really a matter of your overall arrow or bolt setup as to which weight you choose.
If you’re just going with a standard mid-weight bolt setup, then I’d recommend sticking with a 100 grain broadhead because they are readily available and will get the job done. However, if you’re like me and prefer a heavier arrow/bolt setup with a little higher FOC, then a 125 or even a 150 grain may be your best bet.
The past two seasons I’ve shot 150 grain broadheads on my compound bow setup, and I’ve been extremely happy with the results. This year I may go with the 125 grain Slick Trick Magnum, which should still work fine. I can always add another 25 grain weight to my insert if I wanted to keep the overall weight the same, but I really don’t think that will be necessary.
Broadhead selection is a somewhat complex and personal decision. If you’re like me, you probably like trying different things, which is why you’re here checking out new options rather than using what you used last season.
Or maybe you’re new to crossbow hunting altogether. Either way, I hope this information helps you choose the best crossbow broadheads for you specific needs, and that you have your best deer season yet. Shoot straight!